S Australia government questions Billiton desalination EIS
29 Aug 09 by desalination
Desalination discharge led the list of concerns raised by the South Australia government in its submission on 24 April 2009 to BHP Billiton’s environmental impact statement (EIS) related to its proposed expansion of its Olympic Dam mining operations.
The submission identified hydrodynamic modelling, ecotoxicity testing and mitigation strategies for the brine discharge from the proposed 250,000 m³/d seawater desalination plant at to the Upper Spencer Gulf.
Summing up public and other reaction to the EIS, the submission lists the effluent discharge from the proposed Point Lowly desalination plant as the most prominent issue. Overall, more than 95% or 3,800 submissions included comment on the desalination proposal. Of these, around 90% or 3,400 submissions were copies of form letters from the Australian Conservation Foundation and the Wilderness Society, the latter focussed solely on desalination issues.
Billitons’s draft EIS does not indicate the concentration of anti-scalant chemical likely to be released in the discharge, says the government submission, which points out that an appendix states that there is currently no specific ecotoxicity data available for the proposed anti-scalant. The government’s Department of Primary Industries & Resources (PIRSA) has concerns about the possibility that the chemical could cause residue issues with the marine animals in actual and proposed nearby aquaculture farms over the long-term.
PIRSA agrees with the recommendation made by Hydrobiology P/L (who developed the report entitled Ecotoxicity of effluent from the proposed Olympic Dam desalination plant included in the appendix) that further testing must be undertaken once the plant is commissioned and the final make-up of the effluent has been determined.
Further ecotoxicity testing of antiscalant chemicals will have to be undertaken once the final make up of the effluent has been determined; testing is to include residue testing on aquaculture species within the Fitzgerald Bay area. Ideally, the EIS supplement will include results of further ecotoxicity testing of antiscalant chemicals. However, if the final make-up of the effluent has not been determined at the time of the supplement, then it must clearly detail how and when this matter is to be addressed.
Looking at impacts on individual species, the submission questions the World Health Organization (2007) guideline that an incremental level of 10% above ambient salinity is safe. “As these guidelines were not developed for already hypersaline environments, their relevance to this environment is questionable,” says the SA government.
Pipefish, cuttlefish, sponges, crabs and whales are among the species that the government is seeking more impact information about.
The government expects BHP Billiton to review in detail the government submission and the range of public submissions (including the reports of Members or Committees of Parliament), and to prepare a thorough supplementary EIS accordingly.
Login on register to comment
A world leader committed to preserving resources through desalination and reuse
The Group designs
Leading expert delivers online masterclass on membrane fouling
There is only one week left to register for this exciting new format of online event and deepen your understanding of membrane fouling in only one hour.
Singapore International Water Week Turns 10 Years: Celebrating a Decade of Accomplishment in the Global Water Industry
The Singapore International Water Week (SIWW) is the world's premier platform to connect the water industry for innovative solutions and sustainable urban water management. The biennial event gathers stakeholders from the global water industry to share best practices
Related supplier content
Xylem reuse system to up potable water supply in Los Angeles
Water technology company
Sterlitech offers new ultrafiltration membranes
Laboratory products and membrane testing firm Sterlitech is offering Synder Filtration's recently developed ultrafiltration membranes
Osmoflo reports concentrate reduction success
Australian desalination company Osmoflo has reported success with site tests of its concentrate reduction technology for reverse osmosis (RO) plants. The firm said its Brine Squeezer system increased recovery from 80% to 95% in a mine wastewater recovery pilot.