Desalination & Water Reuse Home Page
Search for
The International Desalination & Water Reuse Quarterly industry website
Links
About us   Feedback   Register   Contact   Advertise  

Site Sponsor


FindItForMe!

» What is RSS?
» List of feeds
» Desalination news on your website?

Financing and legal hurdles still ahead for Carlsbad desalination

The labyrinthine complexities of the desalination permitting process in California were further illustrated this week with the latest twists in the Carlsbad seawater desalination plant saga.

At a public hearing on 8 April 2009, the San Diego Regional Water Quality Control Board concluded that the new coastal wetlands proposed by Poseidon as a part of the project will be adequate to mitigate both impingement and entrainment impacts of the desalination plant, when and if it operates as a stand-alone facility in the future.

This, as Nikolay Voutchkov from project promoters Poseidon Resources points out, is unlikely, as the plant will use cooling water from the collocated Encina power station. Since the power station is anticipated to be operational at least for the near future, the actual impingement impact of the plant is expected to be significantly smaller than the assessment presented at the board, which assumes that all of the intake impingement is associated with the desalination plant operations.

The approval was given despite a difference of opinion between Poseidon and the board's staff about precisely how many marine organisms would be affected.

Says Voutchkov, "Since currently neither the US Environmental Protection Agency nor any other regulatory agency worldwide has a methodology of how to assess impingement of marine organisms on intake screens and how to project the amount of such impingement for new projects, Poseidon's experts and the San Diego board's staff had a difference of opinion of what methodology should be used to complete this assessment."

For the site-specific conditions of the Carlsbad project, various impingement assessment methodologies can yield between 1 kg/d and 7 kg/d of the total amount of fish that could be impinged on the intake screens as result of the plant operations. Voutchkov maintains that this could be the daily intake of a couple of pelicans.

"It is logical to conclude that this will not tip the ecological balance along the California coast," he maintains.

On the same day, the San Diego Superior Court issued a tentative ruling rejecting arguments by Surfrider Foundation and the Planning & Conservation League that the California Coastal Commission misapplied state law when it gave Poseidon Resources a coastal development permit to build the plant.

Judge Judith Hayes said the commission's decision was reasonable based on the evidence presented at its November 2007 hearing.

Further legal challenges lie ahead for Poseidon, but permitting is now complete. However, financing is not. Voutchkov estimates all hurdles will be cleared by the last quarter of 2009.

Posted on 13 April 2009  


Email  Send to a friend   Print  Printer friendly   Print  Link to this page    Comment

Source: Desalination & Water Reuse



This story is tagged as:

California | Energy | Environment | Seawater | USA
Click on a keyword to see more stories on that topic

Share this
del.icio.us   digg   technorati cosmos   blinklist   reddit   newsvine   nowpublic   stumbleUpon   Add to diigo
Retweet this on Twitter Facebook  

Make a comment?
Sorry, you must be logged in to post a comment. Click here to login.



© Faversham House Group Ltd 2009. Desalination & Water Reuse news articles may be copied or forwarded for individual use only. No other reproduction or distribution is permitted without prior written consent.

Register Now!



Related Stories

» Marin voters could decide desalination future
» CCC to rule on Cambria desalination plant studies
» West Basin demonstrating desalination intake and outfall technologies
» Agreement at last on desalination supply for Monterey
» Carlsbad desalination challenge dismissed by state board
» Desalination affected by California powerplant ruling
» Environmentalists challenge Cambria desalination test wells
» MoU signed to advance Camp Pendleton desalination plant
» Santa Cruz seawater desalination edges forward
» IDA confirms speakers for Huntington Beach



Links
About us   Feedback   Register   Contact   Advertise  

FHG  
Other Faversham House Websites include
Environment Awards | Builders Merchants Journal | web4water | FHG Media | Heating and Ventilating Review